What The Cluck! Govenders Hauled To Court Over Pets

A Midrand woman has sought legal assistance in order to prevent her neighbours animals from torturing her with the early morning crowing of roosters and other noises.

Anelle van Buuren turned to the Gauteng High Court, Pretoria, to interdict her neighbours – Sadhaseelan and Sarashnee Govender from the noise from their assortment of roosters, turkey and geese.

Describing it as noise pollution, she said she had tried everything to stop the noise which carried on all day. “I approached them on numerous occasions, I approached the SPCA, the City of Johannesburg and the National Prosecuting Authority,” she told the court.

But, she said in court papers, “all my attempts to resolve this  have come to naught.”

She said the Govenders had moved in next door to her in 2013 and set up a pen for poultry on the boundary wall with her  property. But, she said, it was close to her bedroom which faced the wall.

She said her neighbours then packed a variety of poultry,  including roosters, chickens, geese, peacocks and a turkey.

“Needless to say, they caused a lot of noise.”

“The roosters crowed at dusk, throughout the night and into the early morning.

“The peacocks and hens called regularly, especially at dusk and dawn.

The turkey gobbles throughout all hours day and night,” she said.

Van Buuren said the noise had a serious impact on her convenience and peace, as she was woken up during the night and early in the morning by the noise.

“I initially tolerated the noise, thinking the animals will settle down.

“After several months of continuous noise, interrupted sleep and increasing ill health I realised they were not going to settle down.”

Van Buuren said she then spoke to the Govenders about the noise and they moved the pen slightly further from the boundary wall.

But while this perked her up, the prospect of sleep was short-lived, and the noise continued.

She said she once again pleaded with her neighbours to remove the animals, but was told that they were entitled to keep them on the property.

Van Buuren eventually contacted the Gauteng Health Department and officials paid the Govenders a visit.

She was told by the officials that the area was zoned agricultural and so  the noise was reasonable under the circumstances.

However, the Govenders moved the pen further from the wall, and they got rid of some of the roosters.

This helped, Van Buuren said, as there was less crowing, but the noise continued.

Van Buuren said she continued sending frustrated and pleading messages to her neighbours to make a plan.

Van Buuren said she could no longer handle the sleep deprivation. “Sleep deprivation was  a form of torture used in World War 2 and Guantanamo Bay,” she said in her papers.

This, she compared to her own situation, saying the noise was “torturing” her.

But Sarashnee Govender, denied the fowl created noise pollution. She said she had adhered to all calls to move the pen, yet her neighbour continued to complain.

She also accused her neighbour of referring to her and her family in derogatory terms and said she suspected the issue went further than her animals.

She said when she got rid of her chickens, van Buuren turned her attention to the ducks, which were quieter animals.

“At this point we have one rooster, one peacock and ducks. In total we have about 25 poultry.”

Govender pointed out the zoning of the land entitled her to keep her poultry and what she found annoying . She said what was annoying was that Van Buuren herself keeps chickens, and a rooster.

Judge Pierre Rabie did not make an order regarding the interdict at this stage,  but simply ordered the Govenders to pay Van Buuren’s legal costs of the application.

Sources: IOL & MyBroadband


About Indianspice Staff Reporter

Report and write stories for Indianspice.co.za. It is our ambitious goal to cover issues/events/news concerning South Africa and the diaspora.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.